Tuesday, July 12, 2011

Reconstruction Time Again



I have spent a third to a half of the last year living in Warsaw at Dom Pyzik, and somehow have ended up not really writing about it (well, with let's say a few exceptions). Partly this is because I'm working on Something that will have lots and lots about it, partly it is because of having too many other things to do, but for whatever reason this is something that should be addressed. So this post will go to at least try and make up for this rather amiss situation. There's much, much there to write about, although almost all of it that I have planned will be saved for the Something mentioned above, here's a taster; and something to make clear that this blog hasn't completely become a glorified CV.


The thing about Warsaw that everyone knows (other than Joy Division or Bowie references) is that 85% of it was destroyed in 1944, and that it was then reconstructed to the letter after 1945. Strangely, this coexists with another idea of Warsaw as a centre of wide streets, towers and general Warsaw Pact monolithism. Accordingly, for a certain type of architectural critic or historian, Warsaw is irresistible. It is, for traditionalists, the road not travelled - a city where, instead of modernism, we got a dignified reconstruction of the old world. In fact, neither of the statements is exactly true. Recent research makes clear that the 85% figure includes much that was more damaged than irretrievably destroyed, and it's also clear that the reconstructed city took frequently huge liberties with the historical fabric - how could they not? And after some acquaintance with it - ie, through coming here to eat at Pod Samsonem - it's also clear that the modernist objection to the place - as a Disneyfied simulacrum of interest only to tourists - isn't quite right either.


The Old Town is a place of paradox - a project of the Communist Party, it is loved by nationalists; the only 'authentically Polish' part of Warsaw, it is anything but authentic. Here, you can see every one of the four orders of simulation described by Jean Baudrillard in 1981, occurring in Stalinist Poland between 1946 and 1976. It is the sheer inauthenticity, and the only Soviet trimmings that are visible only slightly below the surface, which stop it from being merely cute. Although cute it undoubtedly is. Well, mostly.


The best way to reach the Old Town, or rather the Stare Miasto and Nove Miasto (both are quite impercetibly linked) is via the Trasa W-Z, a West-East promenade that was very much part of the project, and was later lined with tower blocks. Its sandwiching function gives its name to a still-produced local cake. Even before the edges of it started being filled with high-rises, it was a project far from the usual notion of historically scrupulous reconstruction, using as much as possible of the original fabric and street plan. Instead, in order to make the whole apparation of the destroyed city's re-emergence into something functionally viable, a road was cut under and across it. The city's 1950s Stalinist Victory monument was moved here (rather than being demolished) at some point in the 1990s, to the point where she now seems to guard the reconstruction.


Then you get to a glowing, tile-lined underpass, as modern as can be inside but clad in heavy, psuedohistorical masonry, an example of what Vladimir Paperny describes as the heavy, earthbound nature of Stalinist 'Culture Two', where speed itself must of necessity be weighed down. There is, however, a pedestrian route to enter the Old Town from ground level as well, and it is equally unexpected:


It is an underpass with a connecting escalator, and it's a piece of the Moscow Metro in Warsaw. Literally so - the project was designed and built by employees of Moskva Metrostroi. The lamps are Soviet in derivation, showing that peculiar heaven-in-the-bowels-of-the-earth style that was fundamental to Soviet underground systems. the statues, too, are of, first, the People's Army, and second, the builders, who are always also the Builders Of Communism. Both of the sets of statues are under glass panels, very probably to stop them from being vandalised - this protection is also very unexpected in a country which prides itself on anticommunism. So you emerge, in theory, from 1950s Moscow into 17th century Warsaw:


This is the vestibule for the 'Metro'. There was, in fact, a Moscow Metro-style Metro being planned and in some cases even dug around the same time. It was cancelled when the relatively reformist Gomulka regime took power as an expensive vanity project. Gomulka wasn't particularly keen on historical reconstructions either, and said that the Royal Castle would be rebuilt over his dead body. It was, a couple of years after he died - it's the building with the lovely (pre-patinated?) Slavic copper spire in the photograph above. It was built in 1976, although unlike many of the other reconstructed buildings, it doesn't declare the year of (re)construction on it, as if confidence in the illusion had lessened somewhat. From there, you come to the tourist bit:


When the reconstructed Warsaw is praised, it's usually this which is meant - a giant great cobbled square, surrounded by a jagged skyline of sweetly marzipanlike Mitteleuropean buildings, with a market inside. When it is written about, especially by a certain veteran British political commentator/architectural writer, it is usually presented as the Polish capital's agora, its real city centre. Yet it has no tube station, no real facilities other than often very expensive restaurants and stalls with nick-nacks, and hence is surely the Disney city centre that it is often accused of being. The centre of Warsaw, at least in my experience, is defined by the modernist geometry of the Eastern Wall, Stalin's 'gift' of the Palace of Culture and the futurist Central Station - all nearly a mile away. This place is an adjunct, an oddity, divorced from the city's everyday life. Or at least this is what it seems to be, but complexities multiply when you get away from the square.


The Old Town is only one part of reconstructed Warsaw. There are a great many reconstructed 18th century classical buildings, and they are usually a lot less interesting, because this is high architecture, with blueprints, named architects, details that must be reproduced in order for the buildings to really exist as reconstructions. These belong to Baudrillard's first order of simulacra - just the remaking of something that already exists, as faithfully as the technology allows. These are usually just outside the Old Town, leading towards Nowy Swiat and to the city's real 1950s centre. So they're also often interspersed with the modernism of the Gomulka era. But there's another modernism of a sort etched onto the buildings themselves:


What makes the bulk of the old town buildings so interesting is that there isn't really an original, or at least not in the sense of something unchangeable - these were buildings that had been constantly added to and remade over the centuries, so the 1950s could so much the same. These are the second order of Stare Miasto Simulacra. The buildings are vividly coloured to the point where they don't look remotely old, and the sgraffito work, applied in the 1950s, is reminiscent of the animation of the era, the cut-out and montage films by the likes of Jan Lenica. Their cute, angular forms are hardly comparable with the heroic workers of socialist realism, but nor are they abstract. The one below is on the Old Town's only modernist building (ie flat-roofed and without historicist dressing), and it's notable that you barely notice the difference:


These drawings, etchings, paintings and mosaics are deliberately childlike things, cute pieces of 1950s design which have somehow ended up part of a project to evoke the 15th century. To think that they are separate from the ideology is a mistake, however. Look at the two images at the top of this post - one of them of the medieval city undergoing reconstruction, and the other of the Stakhanovite bricklayers who were doing all that work, and at record speeds - and note also that they're in the same cartoonish style as the Little Mermaids above (note also that the second of the two has not been restored - it's best we forget about the 20th century workers who built it). Sometimes they are figurative, neo-renaissance statuary, based on something historically significant that was there before:


and elsewhere, they're straightforward abstraction, of various kinds, either slightly disturbing dismembered bodies, with later and unsubtle additions.


Some of the sgraffito work is also sortof figurative, Disney stuff on some level, the sort of thing that might have been done in medieval Warsaw should they have wanted to do so even if they didn't:


and then there's a move into lush, shimmering, chromatic abstraction.


Step into any of these blocks and you find that they are actually part of another order of simulacra altogether. The majority of these pretty pseudohistorical facades are the masks for public housing, and that's coincidentally the reason why the place lacks the feeling of being a City Centre - because what it really is, is a council estate with sgraffito and restaurants. At times, this is really very vivid - as with the long deck-access block that marks the Old Town's southern corner. Take away the detail, and this is straight-up modernist municipal housing.


That this is a tourist destination, however, can be easily ascertained - the difference is that everyone is home in bed by a sensible time.


But if there's any doubt, just read the other etchings on the walls.


The fourth order of simulacra in the Warsaw Old Town is Mariensztat, a place which really didn't exist before, but which is aesthetically completely of a piece with the earlier orders of simulacra that make up most of it. It's a historical area, but it was completely replanned on a new pattern by the Communist authorities, and became their first showpiece housing estate.


The approach is exactly the same; the painting, now worn enough to almost look convincingly historic; the winding streets; the cobbles; and the sgraffito, which here too is surely the cutest thing ever implemented by the Six Year Plan of an iron-fisted Stalinist regime:


Mariensztat opens out to a large public square, with another very pretty bit of trimming (this time, a mosaic clock) at the corner. If being unkind, one could point out that this is not a style massively unlike that of Nazi architecture at its more vernacular and volkisch (rather than mock-Hellenic) end - Paul Schultze-Naumburg wouldn't have felt completely out of place here. What makes it most unlike the Nazi aesthetic is that strange, out-of-place cutesiness. Not the cutesiness of the carefully worn, and higgledy-piggledy, but of the very 1950s, wholly of-their-time clocks, paintings and drawings. The inspiration seems to come a little from Warsaw's one-time Prussian Gauleiter ETA Hoffmann, a child-like fairy tale uncanniness which is surely the most unlikely response to mass murder in the corpus of public art and city planning. Warsaw had, and still builds, gigantic monuments to its heroism, self-sacrifice and fortitude, but here everything is Lilluputian and pretty. The impulse seems to be comparable to that of post-war modernism, that was remaking the rest of the city by the time the reconstruction was finished - the urge to shake off all of that horrible weight and instead create something light, joyous and dreamlike.


The satellite dishes that line the houses, though, imply that those within the Old Town simulacra have other fantasies and simulations to think about.

50 Comments:

Blogger Post-Continental Satyr said...

Agnetha it looks like a third-rate, run-down, decrepit version of some quaint bourgeois neighbourhood in Holland or in Austro-Hungaria, which in fact is what Poland IS - no matter how hard they suck up to the European Union.

3:36 am  
Blogger Post-Continental Satyr said...

And WHERE is your book???

3:36 am  
Blogger owen hatherley said...

Patience, grasshopper.

12:29 pm  
OpenID yorksranter said...

It really is surprisingly K.u.K. Austrian Poland was disproportionately influential in both countries' history.

2:02 pm  
Blogger owen hatherley said...

If it is, it shouldn't be, given that Warsaw was never occupied by the Austrians (briefly by Prussia, for about a century by the Tsarist Empire)

4:27 pm  
Blogger agata pyzik said...

Post-continental satyr, in a truly post-continental style, you're an undereducated idiot.

6:28 pm  
Blogger Post-Continental Satyr said...

Comrade Pyzik, consider yourself LUCKY that your husband owns a British passport. After three years you can get one as well, and then you can pluck tulips on SELECT Dutch farms, not just any ole stinking Polak farm.

9:59 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I love the sgraffito that Owen remarks but I am not sure it is worth making as much of them as he does.

If you go to any West German town substantially rebuilt after the war, such as Munich or Koln, you will see similar decoration of rebuilt facades.

9:19 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

nike free sales online
nike free run 2 sale
nike free 3.0 sale
nike free 3.0 womens sale
nike free 5.0 sale
womens nike free run 2 sale
nike free run plus 2 black shoes
nike free run plus 2 blue gray shoes
nike free run plus 2 blue gray shoes

10:15 pm  
Anonymous www.encontactos.com said...

It won't truly have success, I believe this way.

10:05 am  
Blogger ekle paylas said...

nice blog Thanks for sharing. voicesohbet was really very nice.
sesli chat siteleri sesli sohbet
sesli sohbet siteleri sesli chat
seslichat seslisohbet
sesli siteleri chat siteleri
sohbet siteleri sesli siteler
voice sohbet

2:32 pm  
Blogger maruthi said...

Wow it's really a nice read. Great article! Very insightful and a good read for anyone interested in travelling articles. It teaches everything one needs to be aware of Poland. I highly recommend this!

Web Designing course

12:18 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Worse then an idiot

12:51 am  
Blogger lisa sparx said...

hairdressers Quotes provides an easy and simple way to search, select and send quote requests to your preferred hairdressers in just a few simple steps. Click the Quotes button to start your hairdressers quote request now.

6:25 pm  
Blogger lisa sparx said...

This comment has been removed by the author.

6:26 pm  
Anonymous Róża said...

I do agree that the Old Town in Warsaw is a kind o simulacrum in Baudrillard's sense but come on - let' s think about the feelings of all these Poles who came back to Warsaw after war and saw their city completely destroyed. This reconstruction is not only the governmental plan to show the power of communists ("we are all rebuilding our capital city") but it tries to restore the years of Warsaw wellness - something that everyone missed during occupation. Please think about heroic effort of polish architects who didn't totally compromised with the party and forced their great ideas (eg. rebuilding "Barss side" of the Main Square). I wouldn't be so harsh in such kind of judgment - here, behinds the architecture there is almost human feelings of hurt city.

1:44 pm  
Blogger Aaliyah theukflight said...

It is worth making as much of them as he does.
Budget Flights To Sydney

12:25 pm  
Blogger Audemars Piguet Watch said...

Austrian Poland was disproportionately influential in both countries' history.
Audemars Piguet Watches

10:59 am  
Blogger petersmith said...

It teaches everything one needs to be aware of Poland.
Pawnbroking

7:46 am  
Blogger petersmith said...

Post-continental satyr, in a truly post-continental style, you're an undereducated idiot.
Pawnbroker

6:47 am  
Anonymous cheap michael kors said...

Hi, thanks I've to mention I'm astonished by your report. In fact qvc coupon codes is rather helpful specifically to on the web individuals.

9:50 am  
Blogger Cahaya Mandiri said...

That is very interesting Smile I love reading and I am always searching for informative information like this. This is exactly what I was looking for. Thanks for sharing this great.
tips cara agar cepat hamil l CARA BELAJAR BAHASA INGGRIS l the best acne treatment l how to lose weight fast easy
margahayuland l BELAJAR BISNIS ONLINE l tips cepat hamil l how to get rid of acne home remedies l
home remedies for acne l how to cure acne fast l
baju batik modern l toko sepatu online l grosir jam tangan online l
jual jam tangan l toko jam tangan murah peluang usaha online l is acne no more for you l how to get rid of acne naturally
how to clear acne l cure acne naturally
best natural remedies for acne l acne no more l tempat belajar bisnis online
peluang usaha rumahan l cara mendapatkan uang dari internet
makanan sehat agar cepat hamil l penyebab tidak bisa hamil lcara agar cepat hamil

2:58 am  
Blogger petersmith said...

It teaches everything one needs to be aware of Poland. I highly recommend this!
Pawnbroker

7:33 am  
Anonymous tips cara agar cepat hamil said...

Very good article, well written and very thought out.This is my first opportunity to visit this website I found some interesting things and I will apply to the development of my blog tips cara belajar bahasa inggris

3:17 am  
Blogger Musa Kocaman said...

Türkiye'nin ve dünyanın her yerine tatil planınızı yapabilirsiniz.

11:07 am  
Anonymous cara membuat toko online said...


Thanks for writing this. I really feel as though I know so much more about this than I did before. Your blog really brought some things to light that I never would have thought about before reading it.
soal-soal cpns ll Asian Brain ll cara cepat hamil ll Tips cepat hamil ll Busana Muslimah Modern ll Toko Baju Muslimah Modern ll rahasia cara memutihkan wajah

5:38 am  
Anonymous akhmadsyahbana said...

I actually have faith in the different guidelines you may have delivered on your blog post. They're just real which enables it to undoubtedly job. Still, any content are far too quite short for freshies. Would you i highly recommend you broaden them a little bit of out of the next occasion? Be grateful for all of the post….
http://akhmadsyahbana.wordpress.com/2013/07/21/mungkin-anda-tertarik-belajar-bisnis-online-gratis-dengan-syamsul-alam/

3:21 pm  
Blogger Muneer Hussian said...

case study solution
case study solution
case study solution
case study solution

case study solution
case study solution
case study solution
case study solution

case study solution
case study solution
case study solution
case study solution

case study solution
case study solution
case study solution
case study solution

case study solution
case study solution
case study solution
case study solution

case study solution
case study solution
case study solution
case study solution

case study solution
case study solution
case study solution
case study solution

case study solution
case study solution
case study solution
case study solution

hbr case solution
hbr case solution
hbr case solution
hbr case solution

case solution
case solution
case solution
case solution

case solution
case solution
case solution
case solution

9:59 am  
Blogger waqas farooq said...

You See Current Affairs in Google, Yahoo or Bing..??? Here is a Best Network of Latest all Hot Current Affairs and News updates. All Hot Current Affairs about Entertainment, Classifieds, Mp3, Funny, Wallpapers, Pictures, Videos, Online Jobs, Online Marketing, Hot News, Hot Updates, Article and Latest News, Latest Mp3 Tunes, Internet Online Jobs, Facebook and Marketing Jobs, Online Marketing, Facebook Marketing, SEO Marketing, Latest Funny Entertainment Hot and Lol pictures and Much More Current Affairs Fun
hotcurrentaffairs.com

2:17 pm  
Blogger Tim Sentraloker said...

Thank you for expressing this info. The details appeared to be quite aid and kept a lot of time. It will totally going to help me in my work .

Lowongan CPNS Kementerian Luar Negeri

3:55 am  
Blogger waqas farooq said...

Free Promotion of your Website, Facebook Page, Twitter, Google Plus, StumbleUpon, Youtube Views Likes and Subscribes, Pinterest, MySpace, SoundCloud, Instagram and Much More Social Media Promotions. Just add your Promotion Link to this Website and Get Increase your Visitors, Page Likes, photo likes, photo shares Twitter Follow Tweets and Favorites, Youtube Views Likes and Subscribes and Much More.
GetLikeFast.com

1:49 pm  
Blogger waqas farooq said...

Free Promotion of your Website, Facebook Page, Twitter, Google Plus, StumbleUpon, Youtube Views Likes and Subscribes, Pinterest, MySpace, SoundCloud, Instagram and Much More Social Media Promotions. Just add your Promotion Link to this Website and Get Increase your Visitors, Page Likes, photo likes, photo shares Twitter Follow Tweets and Favorites, Youtube Views Likes and Subscribes and Much More.
GetLikeFast.com

1:50 pm  
Blogger waqas farooq said...

Free Promotion of your Website, Facebook Page, Twitter, Google Plus, StumbleUpon, Youtube Views Likes and Subscribes, Pinterest, MySpace, SoundCloud, Instagram and Much More Social Media Promotions. Just add your Promotion Link to this Website and Get Increase your Visitors, Page Likes, photo likes, photo shares Twitter Follow Tweets and Favorites, Youtube Views Likes and Subscribes and Much More.
GetLikeFast.com

1:51 pm  
Anonymous http://www.sz-wholesale.com said...

Hello I enjoyed yoiur article. I think you have some good ideas and everytime i learn something new i dont think it will ever stop always new info , Thanks for all of your hard work!.

4:17 am  
Blogger Brad maddox said...

Trading is the Best Business Ever in the World.. All News updates about Forex Business, Latest Currency news updates, latest forex trading business updates, trading updates, forex trading latest news, forex brokers directory, forex brokers list, Dollars news affairs, Stock Markets, stock market news, stock market analysis, technology news, international forex markets, international forex business news and all updates about Forex Trading
ForexAffairs.Com

10:46 pm  
Blogger Best Article Websites said...

I have no words to appreciate this post ..... I'm really impressed with this post .... The person who created this post was a big thank you man for sharing with us.
Advertising agencies in Karachi | Advertising agencies in Pakistan

7:13 am  
Blogger sameer waseem said...

Top Ten Classified Website List, Pakistani Classified Sites, USA Classifieds, Indian Classifieds, Entertainment Articles, Entertainment News, Entertainment Pictures, Bollywood, Hollywood and Lollywood Pictures and Videos, Entertainment Latest updates, Hot Entertainment News and Pictures Funny Entertainment Pictures, lol Pictures, Funny Pictures and every thing you want...
www.hotcurrentaffairs.com

9:31 pm  
Blogger rashid omer said...

All Latest and Current Affairs, News updates about Forex Business. Latest Currency news updates, latest forex trading business updates, trading updates, forex trading latest news, forex brokers directory, forex brokers list, Dollars news affairs, Stock Markets, stock market news, stock market analysis, technology news, international forex markets, international forex business news and all updates about Forex Trading
ForexAffairs.Com

5:19 pm  
Blogger fariya khan said...

Lol is the Laugh out of Laugh where you can Fun Unlimited and Laughing Unlimited. The Best Lol n Troll Network with the Name of Lols Gag... Troll Images, Prank Peoples, Funny Peoples, funny planet, funny facts, funny cartoons, funny movies pics, iphone funny, funny jokes, Prank Images, Fail Pictures, Epic Pictures, Lols and Gags, Lol Pictures, Funny Pictures.
LoLsGag.Coma

8:04 am  
Blogger nida khan said...

Make Money Online is very easy now, In Internet system we have now best earning system without any work, Just Invest some Money into your Business and Make Perfect Life time Earnings with this Business.
Join Now for Make Perfect Business and Earn Money online from home.
www.hotfxearnings.com

2:23 pm  
Blogger Yakenzu Toby said...

This comment has been removed by the author.

9:30 pm  
Blogger Official Kedaibola.com said...

Awesome blog. I enjoyed reading your articles. This is truly a great read for me. I have bookmarked it and I am looking forward to reading new articles. ibcbet, agen sbobet, klik4d, agen bola, sbobet, agen bola


9:34 pm  
Blogger james horticulture said...

friends this article seems to be good one and the way of explaining things are marvelous vertical garden planters

7:04 am  
Anonymous souvenir kawin murah banget anina souvenir said...

hi owen.
i read your book in the weekend and found it great. pulp was a reference point also for my teenage in rome and i found in your thoughts a lot of the thoughts i had at that time, coming out of the side-lines too. although i like this is hardcore (the album) more than you do.

10:37 am  
Blogger tahir shoukat said...

Best Business Plan without any work from Home
Daily Earning 40 Dollars and Monthly earning 1200 Dollars Guaranteed with Payment Proofs
Plan 1, You can Invest as low as 1 Dollar to 100 Dollars and Get Daily profit of 2.50% for 90 Days.
www.hotfxearnings.com

5:13 pm  
Blogger Uzumaki Naruto said...

Good Article, agen souvenir perkawinan murah online. thanks for your article. :)

12:21 pm  
Blogger tahir shoukat said...

Funny Entertainment or Lol Pictures with full of Fun... Entertainment Articles, Entertainment News, Entertainment Pictures, Bollywood, Hollywood and Lollywood Pictures and Videos, Entertainment Latest updates, Hot Entertainment News and Pictures Funny Entertainment Pictures, lol Pictures, Funny Pictures and Much More Fun Only on 1 Current Affairs Network
hotcurrentaffairs.com

3:50 pm  
Blogger samad abbas said...

Top Ten Classified Website List, Pakistani Classified Sites, USA Classifieds, Indian Classifieds, Entertainment Articles, Entertainment News, Entertainment Pictures, Bollywood, Hollywood and Lollywood Pictures and Videos, Entertainment Latest updates, Hot Entertainment News and Pictures Funny Entertainment Pictures, lol Pictures, Funny Pictures and every thing you want...
www.hotcurrentaffairs.com

4:16 pm  
Blogger Uzumaki Naruto said...

Good Article, shika-lirik-nasyid.blogspot.com. thanks for your article. :)

7:12 am  
Blogger Sabeer said...

Nice blog Thanks for sharing. I'm really impressed with this post ....
furniture suppliers in coimbatore

11:28 am  

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home